Captain America: Brave New World – A Bold New Era for the MCU, But Does It Live Up to the Shield?
Rating: 4/5
Director: Julius Onah
Cast: Anthony Mackie, Harrison Ford, Shira Haas, Danny Ramirez, Tim Blake Nelson
Genre: Superhero, Action, Adventure
Runtime: 137 minutes
Release Date: February 14, 2025
Marvel Studios’ Captain America: Brave New World marks the beginning of a new chapter for the MCU, one that’s as much about the future of the franchise as it is about the legacy of its iconic heroes. As the first film to feature Anthony Mackie in the titular role of Captain America following the events of Avengers: Endgame and The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, expectations were naturally sky-high. Can the new Captain America step out of Steve Rogers’ shadow and build a compelling narrative on his own? The answer, for the most part, is a resounding yes—but it’s not without its bumps along the way.
A New Hero for a New World
From the moment Anthony Mackie’s Sam Wilson steps into the role of Captain America, there’s a palpable shift in tone. Gone are the days of Steve Rogers’ idealistic patriotism and stoic leadership. In his place, Sam brings a nuanced, layered approach to the mantle of Captain America. Mackie, who has been a fan favorite since his first appearance as Sam in Captain America: The Winter Soldier, excels here, not just as the man with the shield, but as a character struggling with the weight of it all.
The opening moments of the film reveal a Sam who is still grappling with the idea of being the nation’s symbol of hope and strength, especially as a Black man. The film smartly incorporates themes of identity, legacy, and the cost of heroism, offering a more human, more relatable take on the Captain America mantle than we’ve seen before. Mackie’s performance is heartfelt, at times vulnerable, but never shying away from the power of the role. This isn’t just about carrying a shield—it’s about carrying the weight of an entire nation’s expectations, while trying to reconcile that with personal beliefs.
Harrison Ford’s Red Hulk: The MCU’s New Titan
No discussion of Brave New World is complete without mentioning the legendary Harrison Ford’s entry into the MCU. Ford, who steps into the role of Thaddeus “Thunderbolt” Ross, brings a gravitas to the film that only a veteran actor like him can. But this isn’t just the old, gruff military man fans are familiar with from the Hulk movies. No, in Brave New World, Ross undergoes a drastic transformation—literally. The film introduces Ross as the new President of the United States, but as the film progresses, his descent into the monstrous Red Hulk offers both an intense physical and emotional journey.
Ford plays the character with a quiet menace, using his signature sarcasm and authority to great effect. His evolution from a high-ranking politician to a full-blown antihero/antagonist is one of the film’s highlights, with Ford fully embracing the chaos that Red Hulk embodies. It’s a shift that works incredibly well, not just as an entry into the MCU’s next phase, but as a nuanced exploration of the corrupting influence of power and anger.
The Villain: A Familiar Threat with a New Face
While Red Hulk provides a compelling antagonist, the true threat in Brave New World comes from a mysterious new villain, portrayed by Shira Haas. Without giving too much away, Haas plays a character whose motivations are tied to a dark chapter in the MCU’s history. The narrative cleverly explores the ramifications of creating super-powered beings, touching on the ethical dilemmas of genetic manipulation and military experimentation. This threat feels personal, not just for Sam, but for the world he’s sworn to protect, and it raises the stakes for both Sam and the MCU’s larger narrative.
While Haas does an excellent job with her character, her villainous arc sometimes lacks the depth and complexity that we’ve seen from MCU antagonists like Thanos or Killmonger. Still, her presence is undeniably menacing, and her connection to the events of Avengers: Endgame and beyond makes for an intriguing subplot.
Action, Spectacle, and a New Kind of Captain America
In typical MCU fashion, Brave New World is packed with spectacular set pieces, pulse-pounding action sequences, and mind-bending special effects. From the opening battle in the skies to the final showdown, the film delivers on the action front. The Russo brothers’ influence is still felt here, as the choreography feels fluid and dynamic, showcasing not just Sam’s physical prowess but his intelligence and quick thinking.
The most impressive sequence, however, is a smaller, more intimate moment: Sam’s first true test as Captain America in a tense rooftop chase scene. It’s here that Mackie’s portrayal shines, as the character is forced to rely on his wits rather than brute strength. This is a Captain America who thinks before he acts, and the scene emphasizes that while the shield may be the symbol of power, it’s the man behind it who truly makes the difference.
Visually, Brave New World is stunning. The use of color, especially during the more emotional moments, adds layers to the storytelling. The cinematography embraces a sleek, modern look that is both familiar yet fresh—a fitting backdrop for Sam’s journey into the hero he was always meant to be.
The Heart of the Story: Legacy and Responsibility
At its core, Captain America: Brave New World is a story about legacy—both the legacy Sam inherits and the legacy he chooses to build. The film doesn’t shy away from the complexities of what it means to wear the stars and stripes, but it also embraces the idea that being a hero isn’t about fitting into an ideal mold; it’s about doing what’s right, even when the world is uncertain.
The supporting cast, including Danny Ramirez as the Falcon and Tim Blake Nelson as a familiar MCU character, provides solid performances that help round out the story. While some of the secondary characters feel underdeveloped, particularly in the context of the larger MCU, they serve their purpose in pushing Sam’s arc forward.
The Verdict: A Bold Step Forward
Captain America: Brave New World successfully charts a new course for the MCU, providing a fresh perspective on a beloved character and introducing a world that is still reeling from the chaos of Endgame. Anthony Mackie is nothing short of outstanding, bringing depth, complexity, and humanity to the role of Captain America. Harrison Ford’s Red Hulk is a scene-stealer, adding both weight and excitement to the film’s narrative. While the villain is serviceable, the real power of the film lies in the thematic exploration of what it means to carry a symbol that represents an entire nation—and to do so while remaining true to oneself.
While Brave New World may not quite reach the epic heights of Endgame, it’s a compelling, necessary evolution for the MCU, one that makes you excited for what comes next.
Final Score: 4/5
Would you like to dive deeper into any part of the film, or explore its connections to the MCU’s next phase?
